22 Comments
Jan 16, 2022·edited Jan 16, 2022Liked by Books on GIF

This book made me think of the kids in the "Uni" program where I went to undergrad. It was the Ivy-wannabe college within the school. Those kids definitely seemed smarter than the rest of us. They kind of self-isolated and were aloof and multilingual.

I would love to read spoiler-filled take from you on what happens in the book. And I wish there WAS a movie of it. Heard the Goldfinch adaptation was crap... anyways thank you for another great review and fun gifs!!

Expand full comment
author

Thanks! I feel like I missed out on the true aesthetic of being a philosophy major. I didn't start wearing all black until very recently, and I don't do aloof very well. Alas. Maybe in the next life I'll get it right. I need to figure out how to have spoiler convos. It would be fun to discuss the book with folks who've read it without spoiling it for others or making some exclusive clique among subscribers. Also, I'd have to imagine that some kind of adaptation has to be coming at some point. Maybe it's better suited to a series on a streaming platform instead of a straightforward movie. I could see Apple doing it.

Expand full comment
Jan 17, 2022Liked by Books on GIF

Yeah that makes sense, with all the streaming services needing a constant flow of content... I do love that Maris suggests Timothee Chalamet as Francis.... Maybe for books that are already popular, you could have a separate link/page that goes over your thoughts on the ending. (I would love to discuss with ppl what they thought actually happened during the botched bacchanal. I mean, i know we know but... i would be interested in seeing an on-screen interpretation...)

Expand full comment
author

I could see Chalamet playing Francis, or Richard or even Bunny. But I could see Kieran Culkin as Bunny for sure. Lucas Hedges somewhere in there, too. Maybe Tom Holland and Anya Taylor-Joy as Charles and Camilla? You could have a lot of fun casting the streaming version of this!

Regarding spoilers, etc., I know that some newsletter writers and YouTubers have Discord or Slack platforms for extended conversation and engagement with subscribers. But that is usually tied to some kind of extra subscription cost. I don't know that I have the bandwidth for something like that, with or without a charge, at this point. Maybe after I hit the lottery lol!

Expand full comment
Jan 17, 2022Liked by Books on GIF

Fair enough! I love those casting ideas!!

Expand full comment

I want to like Donna Tartt. I really do, but I just don't. I have friends that are obsessed with The Secret History (to the point where we once just wandered around Bennington College) but it just doesn't do anything for me.

I similarly am not a huge A Little Life person and am super interested to see the backlash against it now.

Great review as always!

Expand full comment
author

Thanks! Yes, it's interesting that all these grumbles about A Little Life are coming out now. It's like there's this group of people who've been silent about it and are now giving voice to their feelings. I think it's totally fine if this book worked for people and if it didn't. There is plenty of room in the world for all reactions. Every book is not meant for every reader. It keeps things interesting!

Expand full comment

I cannot agree with "Every book is not meant for every reader." enough! And that's okay!

Expand full comment

This sounds terrifying. I was the kind of student who went to tea club in the basement of the student union on Friday nights. Though that probably counts as my weird college clique, because surprisingly few students wanted to join a club that got funding from the health center as an alcohol-free alternative weekend activity.

Expand full comment
author

I think tea club sounds pretty fun! I wish I drank tea in college instead of a steady stream of beer and Mountain Dew.

Expand full comment

Is there a point at which you did pick up tea?

Expand full comment
author
Jan 17, 2022·edited Jan 17, 2022Author

Yes, but it wasn't until my 30s when I gave up coffee for the first time. Now I balance both.

Expand full comment
Jan 17, 2022Liked by Books on GIF

As a Nursing major we were weird in a different way. “How was your day? Crap I got a B on a paper. And yours: My patient coded, but lived” so while I went to college with mostly well adjusted friends, we were a tight click because we were growing up quicker than a lot of other students. Not a complaint, just a fact. I LOVED this book. An academic novel is my wheelhouse. So I completely related to the Greek scholars. Plus I felt this was better written than The Goldfinch. Great review. Enjoyed it after a lousy shift. Thanks!

Expand full comment
author

Sorry you had a tough shift, Kate. But I'm glad you enjoyed the review! I definitely want to read another of Donna Tartt's books. But not sure I'll jump straight to The Goldfinch. It's massive!

Expand full comment

Cool discussion here - and weird to think that there's never been a film version of The Secret History. Donna Tartt is one of about six authors I rush out to get as soon as they are published. Very intrigued by the Dark Academia genre.. At risk of sounding wimpy, I love the idea of the "Academia" genre without the darkness!

Expand full comment
author

Thanks! I definitely want to read more of her work. But I may not get to it for a while because I am committed to whittling down a sizable TBR that's been building up on my bedside table. And there's nothing wimpy about wanting an Academia without darkness!

Expand full comment

So, were you stalking the book or was the book stalking you? LOL. I miss the days of bookstore wanderings. I haven't done that in forever as I no longer have the patience since I have kids who will literally run around the place. The Secret History sounds interesting. I like the allure of a mystery to unravel, secret societies, and characters with dark personal secrets.

Expand full comment
author

It was definitely stalking me! I'm sure of it, LOL!

Expand full comment
Nov 22, 2023Liked by Books on GIF

The Little Friend was vastly under- rated, Southern Gothic and unputdownable in parts (as it would have to be, at over 600 pages). We are all waiting for more, Ms Tartt!

Expand full comment
author

Thanks, Cindy! I’m excited to read it. And looking forward to more from her. Hopefully soon!

Expand full comment
Aug 8Liked by Books on GIF

love this review!! definitely check out the goldfinch, pretty sure francis actually has a cameo in it!

Expand full comment
author

Thanks so much! Will do!

Expand full comment