Thanks for an entertaining and interesting review, even though you didn’t care for the book. I’m looking for a novel, so maybe it’s time to check out “Eileen.” I want something to wash away the disappointment of “Asymmetry” by Lisa Halliday. I’m open to suggestions from BoG readers!
Thanks for your thoughtful review. I have never read Ottessa Moshfegh and I won’t start here. I really liked the Olga Tkarzuk book a lot. I thought it was clever and not boring.
My first book by this author, and while I enjoyed her writing style/flow, like you, it just did not gel for me. Vesta goes from a lonely woman obsessing and fantasizing about a mystery to someone who suddenly walks through the looking glass. But why? And what’s the point, beyond a jarring ending? The singular narrative grew tedious over time, as did the long descriptions of her imaginary characters. It was a relief to find your review, as I’m puzzled by the rave reviews where others found a questionable amount of deep symbolism in a plot line that was just repetitive and obtuse to me. I think this might have worked better as a longer short fiction. I’m sufficiently intrigued enough to read more by her.
Hello! Glad you found our review and that it resonated with you. If you're interested in reading more Moshfegh, I'd recommend 'Eileen.' I really enjoyed it.
Thanks, Courtney! I really enjoyed Calvino's 'Invisible Cities,' and I'm excited to dive into this book.
Looking forward to the next review and your take on “If a winter’s night a traveler” great book!
Thanks! I'm really looking forward to reading it this week.
Thanks for an entertaining and interesting review, even though you didn’t care for the book. I’m looking for a novel, so maybe it’s time to check out “Eileen.” I want something to wash away the disappointment of “Asymmetry” by Lisa Halliday. I’m open to suggestions from BoG readers!
'Eileen' is worth a read for sure, but I'm interested in what other folks here would recommend!
Thanks for your thoughtful review. I have never read Ottessa Moshfegh and I won’t start here. I really liked the Olga Tkarzuk book a lot. I thought it was clever and not boring.
Thanks, Kate! Olga T's book is definitely not boring! I'm bummed that this one didn't work for me. I went into it really wanting to like it.
You are not wrong — that is a BIG NOPE re: the murder letter!
I am glad we are on the same page!
My first book by this author, and while I enjoyed her writing style/flow, like you, it just did not gel for me. Vesta goes from a lonely woman obsessing and fantasizing about a mystery to someone who suddenly walks through the looking glass. But why? And what’s the point, beyond a jarring ending? The singular narrative grew tedious over time, as did the long descriptions of her imaginary characters. It was a relief to find your review, as I’m puzzled by the rave reviews where others found a questionable amount of deep symbolism in a plot line that was just repetitive and obtuse to me. I think this might have worked better as a longer short fiction. I’m sufficiently intrigued enough to read more by her.
Hello! Glad you found our review and that it resonated with you. If you're interested in reading more Moshfegh, I'd recommend 'Eileen.' I really enjoyed it.